But the movies definitely feature special twists from peter jackson. At the beginning of the story, frodo is a 33yearold hobbit who has just come of age in hobbit society. The first is the hobbit then the next three books is actually considered only one book. The hobbit is better than the lord of the rings unc mirror. When they were turning those books into three featurelength screenplays, they could handpick the subplots that needed to be there and served the story the most and put them into the movie. The hobbit and the lord of the rings by jrr tolkien. Jan 28, 2015 the lord of the rings told an epic, timeless, classic tale of ultimate goodversusevil. Sep 22, 2019 beren and luthien book, 2017 the fall of gondolin book, 2018 unfinished tales of numenor and middleearth book, 1980 the hobbit book, 1937 the lord of the rings book, 19541955 tv. The hobbit is and was always a little cousin to lord of the rings, a slighter, more lighthearted adventure story set in the same universe.
How does tolkiens the hobbit compare to the lord of rings. Why is the hobbit movie trilogy so bad, compared to the. Tolkiens book the fellowship of the ring and the peter jackson film screenplay of the same name are fairly easy to document because, in both the book and film, the story maintains a single thread from beginning to end. Lord of the rings takes place in the land of middleearth, where there are humans and nonhuman races, such as elves, dwarves, hobbits, trolls, orcs, goblins, etc. So i would like to hear your opions on, which book is the most wellwritten. I now understand the importance of the light of a star to the elves thanks to desolation of smaug. Reasons lord of the rings is better than harry potter. The isnt in any of the lord of the rings films, the first hobbit film, or the book at any point. Although both books had challenges and death along the way, the hobbit was more contained in its stakes, while the lord of the. The theme integration is off the charts, as are the light shows, wizard modes, etc.
All the similarities between the lord of the rings and. The complete list of film changes for the hobbit and the lord. Difference between lord of the rings and the hobbit compare. Book and film differences the hobbit wiki guide ign. The two towers are very difficult to document because of substantial differences in plot sequence. Any time that there is more than one story set in the same universe, then you are just begging for comparison. While the series may have had some lows along with the highs, this unexpected journey really was worth taking so grab your precious as we rank. His books have been translated into more than fifty languages and have sold many millions of copies worldwide. I find the deviations in the hobbit films to be far more offensive than those in the lord of the rings movies. The opening scene is about these rings being forged and given too different types of people like, elves, dwarfs and humans. Tolkien 18921973 is the creator of middleearth and author of such classic and extraordinary works of fiction as the hobbit, the lord of the rings, and the silmarillion. Jun 16, 2019 the lord of the rings cant really be held accountable for having less developed cgi effects than the hobbit, because lotr was made when cgi as a whole was in its infancy and the hobbit was made a few years of technological advancement later. There are many similarities in the two novels as well as film adaptations of the two novels.
Gollum gets to be pretty annoying by the final pages of the lord of the rings. The lord of the rings, and this is supposed to be the sequel to the hobbit from what i have gathered. Lord of the rings versus the hobbit any time that there is more than one story set in the same universe, then you are just begging for comparison. Best lord of the rings characters top 10 hobbit characters chandlerclan top ten differences between the lord of the rings books and films ironsabbathpriest top ten weapons in middle earth lore top ten funniest lord of the rings characters blubbydubber1 hottest male lord of the rings characters top 10 most terrifying lord of the rings characters. I prefer the lord of the rings because of the scale and magnitude of the adventure. The three end credit songs in the first trilogy were incredible.
Its written in a more archaic style of language, uses foreshadowing with a little more subtlety, and it reads pretty much like a classic saga, which it more or less. A good case can be made that the hobbit is a better and more satisfying read than its gargantuan successor, the lord of the rings. There are two major plot threads in this story that are presented very differently, which are. There are many similarities in the two novels as well as fi. Lord of the rings and the hobbit are two very famous novels written in the genre of higher fantasy by j r r tolkein, a popular writer and professor at oxford university. Both books are rich in fantasy, mythology, and adventure, yet each have their own story to tell and the author does this distinctly enough that each story line can. Is it advisable to read the hobbit before reading the lord of the. Is the lord of the rings showing its age, or is it timeless as a realworld depiction of an epic story. I am attempting to document each difference, regardless of whether i personally consider them to be good or bad, major or trivial. Lord of the ringshobbit book characters vs lotrhobbit movie. Five ways in which the hobbit is superior to the lord.
But maybe this dynamic contrast makes it one of the best epics ever told. Tolkiens book, the two towers, and peter jacksons the lord of the rings. I love lord of the rings but now after the final few code updates have to go with hobbit. I agree with most of the changes jackson made in order to translate the lotr books into movies. The story began as a sequel to tolkiens 1937 fantasy novel the hobbit, but eventually developed into a much larger work. However, it is noteworthy some minor plot structures and characterizations were changed, and this altered the scope of the environment and feel in the movies. The lord of the rings and the hobbit trilogies are, of course, based on j. And while i love the lord of the rings and grew up in the shadow of its. The radio dramatisation of the hobbit became a classic when it was first broadcast on bbc radio 4 in 1968 and it continues to delight today. How does tolkiens the hobbit compare to the lord of rings trilogy. The director, who is responsible for all six films in the franchise, added new characters, storylines and battle sequences to amp up the epic series and his mark can be spotted in multiple scenes from the last.
The hobbit is a childrens book, published in 1937, but like the best childrens literature it is for adults as well as youngsters. The lord of the rings books came with reams of material for peter jackson and his cowriters to work from. Its classic joseph campbell stuff and every characters storyline concerns the fate of the entire world they live in. The enchanting prequel to the lord of the rings, the hobbit is the classic fantasy that inspired peter jacksons major motion picture trilogy when thorin oakenshield and his band of dwarves embark upon a dangerous quest to reclaim the hoard of gold stolen from them by the evil dragon smaug, gandalf the wizard suggests an unlikely accomplice. The lord of the rings was also much darker in tone than the hobbit. R download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. You close the book and never want to see the word precious. Hundreds of books have been written about lord of the rings and its deeper, more philosophical meaning, or in the context of the first and. There is no doubt the hobbit is a differently written book than the lord of the rings. Difference between lord of the rings and the hobbit. Alan lee, the oscarwinning conceptual designer for the lord of the rings movie trilogy, discusses his approach to depicting tolkiens imaginary world. But by the second chapter, he becomes a 50 yearold middleaged hobbit for the remainder of the lord of the rings.
The complete list of film changes is my ongoing project to list all the reported differences between peter jacksons hobbit and lord of the rings films and the j. It seems that she was created to provide a strong, relatable female character that doesnt really exist in the hobbit book, and considering her performance was highly praised across the board, it was a move that went rather well. I include not only alterations to the books plot, but also book scenes that are. The hobbit is a fantastic book but shouldnt have been a trilogy of films. Tolkien was able to incorporate more of his world in the lord of the rings trilogy, a world that he had spent years creating look at the backgrounds of history included in his other books such as the silmarilion, the book of lost tales, etc. The book presents more than 150 of lees celebrated illustrations to show how his imagery for both the. Lord of the rings book to movie compare duke university. The lord of the rings is an epic highfantasy novel written by english author and scholar j. Keith johnson, ted estes, and the team did an amazing job on code for the hobbit. I am going the hobbit now and i am floored how much i love this book. John ronald reuel tolkien the lord of the rings is an epic high fantasy novel written by english author and scholar j. In the film the lord of the rings, there is a great evil called sauron.
Does the hobbit sacrifice the elegance of the book for cheap thrills, or does it take a new and exciting take on an old story. One of the best middleearth artists, renown for his work on the hardcover editions of the lord of the rings and the hobbit. It makes it all the easier that tolkien purposefully wrote both stories with decidedly different tones as well as intent. The hobbit was specifically written with children in mind although not in any sense dumbed down, just more focused on story. Lord of the rings facts you need to remember for the hobbit. Tolkien from someone who is new to this series this is the complete book set. Many video games spinoffs also exist, as well as a comic book adaption of the hobbit.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the hobbit lord of the rings. In the box you get the cornerstones of middleearth, the hobbit and the lord of the rings. The lion, the witch and the wardrobe or the lord of the rings the fellowship of the ring. Hobbit film was announced that i realized how i often prefer the story. No amazing music or singing like there was in the first trilogy. The illustrations on the box and on the book covers themselves, are done by alan lee. Lord of the ringshobbit book characters vs lotrhobbit movie characters march 25, 2014 at 9. In the end, the movies just dont align with the book. An unexpected journey is a prequel to his lord of the rings trilogy, which most people rushing to the hobbit will have already seen. The hobbit lord of the rings kindle edition by tolkien, j. When he is introduced in the film, he appears to be a very young hobbit who spends most of his time at play. Tolkiens famous saga, the prelude to the lord of the rings, has all the ingredients of fantasy and adventure. Dirt from the lothlorien garden, some of the last to grow the best plants in all of middle earth and he used it over the entire shire. The whole film is based on the theme of good vs evil.
When it comes to comparing the movie trilogy and the original books, the overall plot structure of the movies followed faithfully to the original. Well, the book i was thinking of when i talk about narnia, was the book the lion, the witch and the wardrobe. The lord of the rings trilogy or the hobbit trilogy. Lord of the rings star critiques the hobbit films reliance on cgi. The complete list of film changes for the hobbit and the lord of. However, the short and sweet single hobbit book contained enough material for just one tight.
Top ten differences between the hobbit book and films. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the faq by clicking the link above. This content is intended for adult audiences and is not suitable for children. No fantasy film series can compare to those created from the works of visionaries j. This is a departure from the canon, but it does still have roots in the original books for the lord of the rings, in which it is often stated that frodo loves hearing tales of his uncles.
859 888 519 1101 1634 1473 474 287 1172 628 78 188 1305 1136 947 480 150 636 426 1436 1386 156 49 1469 1347 1624 662 1089 1022 582 1632 1275 644 1125 740 37 1240 267 914 943 859 170 224 342 1384 778 828